Mandated Fat Camps?

That’s the question you could be asking if these guys get their way.
An idea that seems to be gaining traction in the discussion on reducing the cost of health care is the notion of increasing taxes on foods that contribute to obesity. High calorie, high in fat products would simply cost more.. The idea being that you would be discouraged from buying those items just as smokers are discouraged from smoking, and pushed toward healthier eating habits.
Cal Thomas in USA today said: “Here's an idea you should like. We impose high taxes on cigarettes in part to discourage smoking, but also for the stated purpose of paying for some of the health costs associated with the habit. I might support a tax on sugary soft drinks, quarter-pounders with cheese and other high calorie, high in fat products — if the money would be reserved for subsidizing poor people and their insurance needs. And how about a reward for good behavior: a tax credit for those who work out, buy exercise equipment, join gyms, lose weight and eat right? A doctor's note could serve as proof for the IRS!”
Bob Beckel responded: “Cal Thomas for a tax increase? Be still my heart! It is a solid idea, as are tax credits for the working poor to purchase health plans and credits for getting healthy — especially at a young age. According to a report last week, the country spent $147 billion on weight-related medical bills last year. An obese patient averaged $4,871 in such bills compared with $3,442 for a patient at a healthy weight. There is common ground all over that.”
Where planet are they on? This is an example of policy design by people who have no idea how the average person lives. This concept would place a much larger burden on the poor and the working poor than anyone else. Maybe we could have government run fat camps to get the weight off - they could be free! After all the government would just be looking after you. How about that!